Visual State Management Audit: Identifying Data Leaks in Legacy Web Applications

Your legacy CRM is leaking PII, and your developers don't even know it. In a monolithic AngularJS or jQuery application, state isn't just a variable; it’s a ghost that haunts the global

object, persisting long after a user has navigated away from a sensitive screen. When data from a "Customer Profile" view lingers in memory while a user is on the "Public Dashboard," you don't just have a performance bug—you have a critical security vulnerability.

The $3.6 trillion global technical debt crisis is fueled by these invisible leaks. According to Replay’s analysis, 67% of legacy systems lack any form of up-to-date documentation, making manual code reviews for state persistence nearly impossible. To secure these systems, you need a visual state management audit—a process that maps what the user sees to how the data is stored, mutated, and, crucially, destroyed.

TL;DR:

• •Legacy applications often suffer from "state pollution" where sensitive data persists in memory across different user sessions or views.
• •A visual state management audit identifies where UI components are holding onto stale or insecure data.
• •Replay automates this by converting video recordings of user workflows into documented React components, reducing audit time from 40 hours per screen to just 4.
• •Modernizing state management is the most effective way to prevent data leaks in regulated industries like Healthcare and Finance.

---

Why a Visual State Management Audit is the First Step in Modernization#

Legacy systems are often "black boxes." You see the UI, but the underlying data flow is a spaghetti mess of global variables, DOM-bound data attributes, and hidden singleton services. Industry experts recommend a visual-first approach because the UI is the only source of truth that hasn't decayed over time.

A visual state management audit isn't just about looking at code; it’s about observing the lifecycle of data as it moves through the application. When you record a workflow using Replay, you aren't just capturing pixels—you are capturing the intent and the state transitions that drive those pixels.

Video-to-code is the process of using computer vision and AI to interpret UI recordings, extracting the underlying logic, component hierarchies, and state structures into modern, readable code.

The Cost of Stale State#

When state management fails, the consequences are expensive. 70% of legacy rewrites fail or exceed their timeline because architects underestimate the complexity of existing data flows. A manual audit of a single complex screen can take up to 40 hours. With Replay, that timeline drops to 4 hours, representing a 70% average time savings.

---

Identifying the "State Ghosts" in Your Legacy Stack#

In legacy environments—specifically those built 10+ years ago—state was often managed by directly manipulating the DOM. This creates "State Ghosts": data that exists in the browser's memory but has no clear owner in the source code.

Common Sources of Data Leaks:#

1. •The Global Window Object: Developers often attached objects to
   text

   window.userData
   for "convenience," forgetting to nullify them on logout.
2. •jQuery
   text

   .data()
   Cache: Data attached to DOM nodes that are hidden (but not removed) remains accessible to scripts.
3. •Zombie Listeners: Event listeners that reference large data objects, preventing garbage collection.
4. •Insecure LocalStorage: Storing PII in unencrypted browser storage that persists across sessions.

During a visual state management audit, we look for discrepancies between the UI state and the memory heap. If the UI shows a "Logged Out" screen, but the memory heap still contains a

object, you have a leak.

Modernizing Legacy UI Architecture

---

Executing a Visual State Management Audit for Enterprise Systems#

To perform a thorough audit, you must follow a structured framework that moves from visual observation to technical validation.

Step 1: Workflow Recording#

Record a real user workflow using Replay’s Flows. This captures every state transition, API call, and UI change. In regulated environments like Healthcare or Insurance, this provides an immutable record of how data is handled.

Step 2: Component Deconstruction#

Using Replay's Library, the recorded video is decomposed into functional components. This allows you to see exactly which piece of the UI is responsible for which piece of data.

Step 3: State Mapping#

Compare the legacy implementation (e.g., a Backbone.js Model) with the desired modern state (e.g., a React Context or Zustand store).

Legacy Code Example: The "Leak" Pattern

In this jQuery-era snippet, notice how data is globally scoped and never cleaned up, a common finding during a visual state management audit.

typescript
// LEGACY: Highly susceptible to data leaks
(function($) {
    window.AppCache = {}; // Global pollution

    $(document).on('click', '.user-row', function() {
        const userId = $(this).data('id');
        
        // Fetching sensitive data
        $.get('/api/user/' + userId, function(data) {
            window.AppCache.currentUser = data; // Data stays here forever
            renderProfile(data);
        });
    });

    function renderProfile(user) {
        $('#profile-name').text(user.fullName);
        $('#profile-ssn').text(user.ssn); // Sensitive data in DOM
    }
    
    // NO CLEANUP ON NAVIGATION
})(jQuery);

Modernized Code Example: The Replay Output

When Replay processes the recording of this workflow, it generates a clean, encapsulated React component with proper state boundaries and cleanup logic.

typescript
import React, { useState, useEffect } from 'react';
import { useUserStore } from './store';

interface UserProfileProps {
  userId: string;
}

export const UserProfile: React.FC<UserProfileProps> = ({ userId }) => {
  const [user, setUser] = useState<UserData | null>(null);
  const { clearUser } = useUserStore();

  useEffect(() => {
    let isMounted = true;

    async function fetchUser() {
      const response = await fetch(`/api/user/${userId}`);
      const data = await response.json();
      if (isMounted) setUser(data);
    }

    fetchUser();

    // Cleanup: Prevents state leaks and zombie data
    return () => {
      isMounted = false;
      clearUser();
      console.log('State cleared for user:', userId);
    };
  }, [userId, clearUser]);

  if (!user) return <SkeletonLoader />;

  return (
    <div className="profile-container">
      <h3>{user.fullName}</h3>
      {/* Sensitive data handled via secure context, not global window */}
      <SecureField value={user.ssn} label="SSN" />
    </div>
  );
};

---

The Role of AI in Visual State Management Audits#

Manual audits are prone to human error. An architect might miss a single

that holds a reference to a large object. According to Replay's analysis, AI-assisted audits identify 4x more potential data leaks than manual code reviews in legacy codebases.

The Replay AI Automation Suite analyzes the "Flows" of your application. It detects patterns where data enters the system but lacks a corresponding "exit" or "cleanup" pattern. This is critical for meeting SOC2 and HIPAA requirements, where data persistence must be strictly controlled.

From 18 Months to Weeks#

The traditional enterprise rewrite timeline is 18 months. This is largely due to the "Discovery Phase"—the months spent trying to figure out how the old system actually works. By starting with a visual state management audit via Replay, you skip the guesswork. You move directly from "What is this doing?" to "Here is the documented React code."

How to Accelerate Design System Extraction

---

Visualizing Technical Debt: The Impact of $3.6 Trillion#

The global technical debt isn't just a number; it’s a bottleneck for innovation. When 70% of your budget is spent maintaining legacy systems, you can't compete with agile startups.

A visual state management audit provides the data needed to justify a modernization budget to stakeholders. Instead of saying "the code is messy," you can show a visual map of where PII is leaking and provide a blueprint for the fix.

Replay Blueprints act as the bridge between the old and the new. They provide an editor where architects can refine the AI-generated components, ensuring that the new state management logic aligns with enterprise standards.

---

Frequently Asked Questions#

What is a visual state management audit?#

A visual state management audit is a technical review process that identifies how data is stored, displayed, and cleared in a web application by mapping UI actions to memory state. It is used primarily in legacy modernization to find data leaks and "zombie" states that could lead to security vulnerabilities or performance degradation.

How does Replay help with data leak detection?#

Replay records real user workflows and uses visual reverse engineering to extract the underlying state logic. By converting these recordings into documented React code, Replay makes it easy to see where legacy state (like global variables) is failing to be cleaned up, allowing architects to implement proper lifecycle hooks in the modernized version.

Can Replay work with older frameworks like AngularJS or Silverlight?#

Yes. Because Replay uses a visual-first approach (Video-to-code), it is framework-agnostic. It records the rendered output and user interactions, then uses AI to map those patterns into modern React components and Design Systems, regardless of whether the source was jQuery, AngularJS, or even legacy Java-based web portals.

Is Replay secure for use in regulated industries?#

Absolutely. Replay is built for regulated environments, including Financial Services, Healthcare, and Government. It is SOC2 compliant, HIPAA-ready, and offers On-Premise deployment options for organizations that cannot allow data to leave their internal network.

Why is manual state auditing so slow?#

Manual auditing requires a developer to trace every possible code path in a codebase that likely lacks documentation. In a legacy app with 67% missing documentation, this involves "archaeological coding"—digging through layers of old scripts to find where a variable was first defined. Replay automates this by observing the application in its running state, which is always accurate.

---

Conclusion: Modernize with Confidence#

Don't let your legacy system be a liability. A visual state management audit is the most efficient way to map your path from a fragile, leaking monolith to a secure, modern React architecture. By leveraging Replay, you reduce the risk of rewrite failure and ensure that your new system is documented, performant, and secure from day one.

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay