Visual Reverse Engineering vs. Static Code Analysis: Which Is Better for UI?

70% of legacy modernization projects fail because architects treat the user interface as a static artifact. They spend months performing "code archaeology" on undocumented repositories, only to find that the source code doesn't reflect the actual business logic running in production. With $3.6 trillion in global technical debt looming over enterprise balance sheets, the industry can no longer afford the 18-month "Big Bang" rewrite.

TL;DR: While Static Code Analysis provides a map of the past, Visual Reverse Engineering captures the reality of the present by recording live workflows to generate documented, production-ready React components in days rather than months.

The Archaeology Trap: Why Static Code Analysis Fails the UI#

Static Code Analysis (SCA) has been the gold standard for backend refactoring for decades. It parses Abstract Syntax Trees (ASTs), identifies vulnerabilities, and maps dependencies. However, when applied to the frontend, SCA hits a brick wall. Modernizing a legacy UI isn't just about moving code; it’s about capturing intent.

67% of legacy systems lack any form of up-to-date documentation. In these environments, the source code is often a graveyard of commented-out logic, dead CSS, and "temporary" hacks that have survived for a decade. If you use SCA to guide your modernization, you aren't just migrating the system—you’re migrating the debt.

The Runtime Reality Gap#

Legacy UIs in financial services or healthcare are often highly state-dependent. A single PHP or JSP file might render ten different views based on complex session data that SCA cannot see. Static analysis looks at the "dead" code on the disk. Visual Reverse Engineering looks at the "living" code in the browser.

Defining Visual Reverse Engineering#

Visual Reverse Engineering is the process of recording a live application's execution—capturing the DOM, state transitions, and network calls—and using AI to reconstruct that functionality into a modern stack.

Instead of guessing what a legacy

does by reading 500 lines of spaghetti jQuery, Replay records the user clicking "Submit," captures the exact JSON payload sent to the server, observes the UI's reaction to the response, and generates a clean, typed React component that replicates that exact behavior.

💰 ROI Insight: The average enterprise rewrite takes 18-24 months. By using Replay to extract components directly from the browser, teams reduce that timeline to weeks, achieving an average of 70% time savings.

Step-by-Step: From Legacy Black Box to Documented Codebase#

To move from a monolithic "black box" to a modular React architecture, you need a repeatable process. Here is how enterprise teams leverage Replay to bypass the manual rewrite phase.

Step 1: Workflow Recording#

The process begins by running the legacy application and recording a specific business process (e.g., "Onboard New Insurance Claimant"). Replay acts as the "source of truth," capturing every interaction.

Step 2: Extraction and Decomposition#

Replay's engine analyzes the recording to separate the UI into logical components. It identifies patterns, such as recurring buttons or form inputs, and maps them to your new Design System.

Step 3: API Contract Generation#

One of the biggest hurdles in modernization is the lack of backend documentation. Replay monitors the network tab during your recording to generate precise API contracts.

typescript
// Example: API Contract Generated by Replay from a legacy SOAP-to-REST wrapper
export interface ClaimantOnboardingRequest {
  claimId: string;
  policyNumber: string; // Extracted from DOM input 'policy_no_01'
  incidentDate: string; // ISO format enforced by Replay transformation
  metadata: {
    browserAgent: string;
    sessionRef: string;
  };
}

export async function submitClaim(data: ClaimantOnboardingRequest) {
  const response = await fetch('/api/v2/claims/onboard', {
    method: 'POST',
    body: JSON.stringify(data),
    headers: { 'Content-Type': 'application/json' }
  });
  return response.json();
}

Step 4: Component Generation#

Replay takes the visual and functional data and outputs a clean React component. This isn't a "transpilation" of old code; it's a fresh build based on the behavior observed.

tsx
// Example: React Component extracted from a 2012-era ASP.NET screen
import React, { useState } from 'react';
import { Button, TextField, Card } from '@enterprise-ds/core'; // Integrated with your Design System

export const LegacyClaimForm: React.FC = () => {
  const [loading, setLoading] = useState(false);

  const handleLegacySubmit = async (event: React.FormEvent) => {
    event.preventDefault();
    setLoading(true);
    // Logic preserved from Replay's Flow Analysis
    console.log("Executing legacy validation logic...");
    // ... API call logic
    setLoading(false);
  };

  return (
    <Card title="Claim Submission">
      <form onSubmit={handleLegacySubmit}>
        <TextField label="Policy Number" required />
        <Button type="submit" loading={loading}>
          Submit Claim
        </Button>
      </form>
    </Card>
  );
};

⚠️ Warning: Never attempt a "Big Bang" rewrite without first capturing the E2E test state. Replay automatically generates Playwright or Cypress tests from your recordings to ensure zero regression.

Why Technical Decision Makers are Switching to Replay#

The "Modernize without rewriting" philosophy is gaining traction in regulated industries (Financial Services, Healthcare, Government) because it addresses the three pillars of enterprise risk:

1. •Documentation Gaps: Replay creates a "Blueprints" library. Even if your original developers left the company in 2015, you now have a visual and technical map of how the system works.
2. •Logic Preservation: In complex insurance or telecom systems, business rules are often buried in the UI logic. Static analysis might miss a
   text

   setTimeout
   or a conditional CSS class that triggers a critical calculation. Visual Reverse Engineering catches it because it happens on screen.
3. •Security and Compliance: Replay is built for regulated environments. With On-Premise availability and SOC2/HIPAA readiness, you can modernize sensitive systems without data leaving your perimeter.

Comparing the Modernization Paths#

The "Strangler Fig" Strategy with Replay#

Most architects prefer the Strangler Fig pattern—gradually replacing legacy modules with new ones. Replay accelerates this by allowing you to extract one "Flow" at a time. You can record the "User Profile" flow, extract it, and deploy it as a modern React micro-frontend while the rest of the legacy monolith continues to run.

📝 Note: Replay's "Library" feature allows you to sync extracted components directly to your internal Design System, ensuring that every modernized screen is instantly brand-compliant.

Frequently Asked Questions#

How does Visual Reverse Engineering handle obfuscated or minified code?#

Because Replay focuses on the DOM, network requests, and runtime state, the readability of the original source code is irrelevant. We look at the output and the behavior. Whether the legacy code is minified JavaScript or a compiled Java Applet, if it renders in a browser, Replay can extract the intent and reconstruct it in React.

What about business logic that doesn't have a visual component?#

Replay’s AI Automation Suite analyzes the network traffic (API Contracts) and state changes that occur behind the scenes during a recording. While the focus is on the UI, the "Flows" feature maps out the sequence of backend calls, ensuring that the business logic is preserved in the generated documentation and tests.

Can Replay work with old technologies like Silverlight or Flash?#

If the application can be rendered in a modern browser (via emulators or legacy support modes), Replay can capture the interaction. For most enterprises, the focus is on migrating from AngularJS, jQuery, or server-side rendered frameworks (JSP, JSF, ASP.NET) to modern React.

How much time does it actually save?#

On average, our partners see a reduction from 40 hours of manual work per screen to just 4 hours. This includes the time to record, extract, audit the generated code, and integrate it into the new repository.

---

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.