The Sunk Cost Fallacy in 24-Month Modernization Roadmaps

The 24-month modernization roadmap is a corporate suicide note signed by the CIO and delivered by the Enterprise Architect. It is a document built on a foundation of "The Sunk Cost" fallacy—the irrational belief that because we have already invested millions into a legacy stack, we must spend millions more to rebuild it from the ground up.

Statistically, if you are six months into a two-year "Big Bang" rewrite, you are already failing. 70% of legacy rewrites fail to meet their original objectives or exceed their timelines by over 100%. With a global technical debt mountain reaching $3.6 trillion, the industry’s obsession with "starting over" isn't just inefficient; it’s negligent.

TL;DR: Stop treating legacy systems as "trash to be replaced" and start treating them as "specifications to be extracted"—Visual Reverse Engineering with Replay cuts modernization timelines from years to weeks by turning user workflows into documented React code.

The $3.6 Trillion Anchor: Understanding the Sunk Cost#

The Sunk Cost fallacy in enterprise architecture manifests as a desperate commitment to a failing strategy simply because of the resources already consumed. We see this in Financial Services and Healthcare constantly: a bank spends $50M on a 10-year-old Java monolith, realizes it can't support modern API requirements, and then commits another $100M to a "Cloud Native" rewrite that will take three years.

By the time the rewrite is finished, the "modern" stack is already three versions behind, and the original business requirements have shifted.

Why the "Big Bang" Rewrite is Architectural Suicide#

The primary reason these projects fail isn't a lack of talent; it's a lack of information. 67% of legacy systems lack any form of up-to-date documentation. When you attempt to rewrite a system from scratch, you aren't just writing code; you are performing "software archaeology."

Developers spend 80% of their time trying to figure out what the old system actually does by reading obfuscated code or interviewing users who have forgotten why a specific "workaround" exists.

The Archaeology Problem: Why Manual Documentation Fails#

Manual reverse engineering is a bottleneck that kills momentum. On average, it takes a senior engineer 40 hours per screen to manually document, map business logic, and recreate a legacy UI in a modern framework like React. In a system with 200 screens, that’s 8,000 man-hours—roughly four years of work for a single developer just to get back to parity.

⚠️ Warning: Most modernization projects fail during the "Discovery Phase" because the gap between what the business thinks the app does and what the code actually does is too wide to bridge manually.

Replay changes this dynamic by using the application's execution as the source of truth. Instead of reading dead code, we record live workflows. If a user in a claims processing center executes a complex multi-step approval, Replay captures the state, the API calls, the UI components, and the underlying business logic.

From Black Box to Documented Codebase#

The future of modernization isn't rewriting; it's understanding. Replay’s Visual Reverse Engineering platform allows you to record a session and immediately generate a library of React components and documented flows.

💰 ROI Insight: By moving from manual documentation (40 hours/screen) to Replay-assisted extraction (4 hours/screen), enterprises realize a 90% reduction in discovery costs and a 70% average time savings on the total project.

The Replay Methodology: A 3-Step Pivot#

Instead of the 24-month roadmap, we advocate for the "Extraction Sprint." Here is how technical leaders are using Replay to bypass the Sunk Cost trap.

Step 1: Recording the Source of Truth#

Engineers or Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) run through the legacy application. Replay records the DOM mutations, network traffic, and state changes. This is not a video recording; it is a high-fidelity capture of the application’s DNA.

Step 2: Visual Reverse Engineering & AI Automation#

The Replay AI Automation Suite analyzes the recording. It identifies recurring UI patterns and maps them to a centralized Library (Design System). It identifies the "Flows"—the sequence of events that constitute a business process.

Step 3: Blueprint Generation#

The platform generates Blueprints. These are not just snippets; they are functional React components, API contracts (Swagger/OpenAPI), and E2E tests (Playwright/Cypress) that mirror the legacy behavior exactly.

typescript
// Example: Replay-Generated Component with Preserved Business Logic
// Source: Legacy Insurance Claims Portal (Delphi/Web-Wrapper)
// Target: Modern React + Tailwind

import React, { useState, useEffect } from 'react';
import { ClaimHeader, ValidationAlert } from '@/components/ds-library';
import { useClaimsAPI } from '@/hooks/useClaimsAPI';

export const ClaimsProcessor = ({ claimId }: { claimId: string }) => {
  const { data, loading, error } = useClaimsAPI(claimId);
  const [status, setStatus] = useState(data?.status || 'PENDING');

  // Business Logic Extracted from Workflow: 
  // "If claim > $5000 and region is 'NE', require secondary adjuster"
  const requiresEscalation = data?.amount > 5000 && data?.region === 'NE';

  if (loading) return <SkeletonLoader />;

  return (
    <div className="p-6 space-y-4">
      <ClaimHeader title={`Claim #${claimId}`} priority={requiresEscalation ? 'HIGH' : 'NORMAL'} />
      
      {requiresEscalation && (
        <ValidationAlert 
          message="Secondary Adjuster Signature Required per Legacy Rule 402-B"
          type="warning" 
        />
      )}

      <form className="grid grid-cols-2 gap-4">
        {/* Replay-generated fields mapped to legacy API schema */}
        <input defaultValue={data?.policyHolder} readOnly className="input-disabled" />
        <button 
          onClick={() => handleApproval(claimId)}
          disabled={requiresEscalation && !data?.adjusterSigned}
          className="btn-primary"
        >
          Approve Claim
        </button>
      </form>
    </div>
  );
}

Preserving Business Logic in Regulated Environments#

For industries like Financial Services and Healthcare, the "Big Bang" rewrite isn't just slow; it's a compliance nightmare. Every line of new code must be audited against HIPAA or SOC2 requirements.

When you use Replay, you aren't "guessing" the logic; you are extracting the validated, audited logic that is already running in production. Replay provides a Technical Debt Audit and API Contracts automatically, ensuring that the new system talks to the existing backend exactly like the old one did.

💡 Pro Tip: Use Replay's "Flows" feature to map out edge cases that your current developers don't even know exist. The "forgotten" logic is usually where the bugs live in a rewrite.

Automated E2E Test Generation#

One of the most significant risks in modernization is regression. How do you know the new React app behaves exactly like the 20-year-old PowerBuilder app? Replay generates E2E tests based on the original recording.

typescript
// Generated Playwright Test for Regression Testing
import { test, expect } from '@playwright/test';

test('Verify Modernized Claims Flow matches Legacy Workflow', async ({ page }) => {
  await page.goto('/claims/new');
  
  // These interactions mirror the SME recording exactly
  await page.fill('[data-testid="policy-number"]', 'POL-8872');
  await page.click('[data-testid="validate-btn"]');
  
  // Replay captured that this specific legacy state triggers a modal
  const modal = page.locator('.legacy-modal-overlay');
  await expect(modal).toBeVisible();
  
  await page.selectOption('select[name="claimType"]', 'AUTO');
  await page.click('text=Submit');
  
  // Verify API Contract integrity
  const response = await page.waitForResponse(res => res.url().includes('/api/v1/claims'));
  expect(response.status()).toBe(201);
});

Challenging the "Modernize = Rewrite" Dogma#

The industry needs to stop treating "Legacy" as a dirty word. Legacy code is code that is actually making money. The "Sunk Cost" is only a trap if you continue to pour money into manual processes that yield no results for 18 months.

Replay allows you to:

1. •Stop Archaeology: Use video as the source of truth.
2. •Eliminate the Documentation Gap: 67% of systems have no docs; Replay generates them in real-time.
3. •Ship in Days, Not Years: By automating the extraction of UI and logic, you bypass the "Discovery Death Spiral."

📝 Note: Replay is built for enterprise-grade security. Whether you need SOC2 compliance, HIPAA-ready environments, or an On-Premise deployment for air-gapped government systems, the platform is designed to sit inside your security perimeter.

Frequently Asked Questions#

How long does legacy extraction take with Replay?#

While a traditional manual rewrite takes 18-24 months, Replay typically reduces this to 2-8 weeks. The discovery phase for a single complex screen is reduced from 40 hours to approximately 4 hours.

What about business logic preservation?#

Replay doesn't just copy the UI. It records the state changes and network calls associated with every user action. This allows the platform to generate functional components that maintain the original business rules, even if the original source code is undocumented or written in a deprecated language.

Does Replay replace my developers?#

No. Replay is a force multiplier for Enterprise Architects and Senior Developers. It removes the "grunt work" of reverse engineering and documentation, allowing your team to focus on high-value architectural decisions and new feature development.

Can Replay handle mainframe or terminal-based systems?#

Yes. If the application can be accessed via a web wrapper, Citrix, or a terminal emulator with a web interface, Replay can record the workflows and extract the logical components into modern web frameworks.

Is the generated code maintainable?#

Yes. Replay generates clean, idiomatic React (or your framework of choice) that follows your specific Design System. It is not "spaghetti code" or a black-box library; it is standard code that your developers will own and maintain.

---

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.