The SME Crisis: How Visual Behavioral Capture Eliminates the Need for Legacy Subject Matter Experts

The most dangerous person in your IT organization is the Subject Matter Expert (SME) who plans to retire in six months. In the world of enterprise systems, "tribal knowledge" is often the only thing keeping $3.6 trillion in global technical debt from collapsing. When the person who understands the Byzantine logic of a 30-year-old insurance claims portal leaves, they take the blueprints of your business with them.

Traditional modernization efforts fail because they rely on these human bottlenecks. We spend months interviewing SMEs, only to find that their understanding of the system is based on how it should work, not how it actually works. According to Replay’s analysis, 67% of legacy systems lack any form of accurate documentation, leaving architects to play a high-stakes game of digital archaeology.

Visual behavioral capture eliminates this dependency by shifting the source of truth from human memory to observed system behavior. By recording real user workflows and programmatically converting those interactions into documented React code, platforms like Replay bypass the need for SME interviews entirely.

TL;DR: Legacy modernization is traditionally stalled by a lack of documentation and the scarcity of Subject Matter Experts (SMEs). Visual Behavioral Capture is a "Video-to-Code" technology that records user interactions to automatically generate modern React components, design systems, and workflow documentation. This approach reduces modernization timelines from years to weeks, achieving a 70% average time savings and ensuring that technical debt is resolved without relying on retiring personnel.

---

Why Visual Behavioral Capture Eliminates the SME Bottleneck#

The fundamental problem with legacy modernization isn't the code; it’s the intent. When you look at a COBOL backend or a Delphi-based desktop UI, you aren't just looking at syntax—you're looking at decades of undocumented business rules.

Visual Behavioral Capture is the process of recording high-fidelity user sessions and using computer vision and metadata analysis to reconstruct the underlying application logic, UI components, and data flows.

In a typical enterprise environment, extracting this logic manually takes roughly 40 hours per screen. You have to schedule meetings with SMEs, record their screens, write down the requirements, hand them to a designer to recreate in Figma, and then hand them to a developer to code in React. This process is why the average enterprise rewrite timeline stretches to 18 months.

Visual behavioral capture eliminates this friction by automating the extraction. Instead of asking an SME "What happens when you click this button?", you simply record them clicking it. Replay captures the visual state, the DOM transitions (or pixel changes in VDI environments), and the behavioral triggers.

The Cost of Human-Centric Modernization#

Industry experts recommend moving away from "interview-based" requirements gathering. As systems grow in complexity, the gap between what an SME remembers and what the code executes widens. Modernizing without rewriting from scratch requires a data-driven approach to component discovery.

---

How Visual Behavioral Capture Eliminates Documentation Gaps#

Most legacy systems are "black boxes." You feed data in, and data comes out, but the intermediate UI states are a mystery. When 67% of systems lack documentation, your developers are essentially flying blind.

Video-to-code is the transformation of visual recordings into functional, structured source code and architectural diagrams.

By using Replay, teams can generate a "Flow"—a visual map of every state transition within an application. This visual behavioral capture eliminates the need to guess how a multi-step form handles validation or how a legacy navigation menu handles deep linking.

From Pixels to TypeScript: The Technical Translation#

When Replay captures a session, it doesn't just record a video file. It analyzes the visual hierarchy to identify patterns. It sees a recurring header, a consistent button style, and a specific data table structure. It then maps these to a centralized Library (Design System).

Here is an example of what the output looks like when Replay converts a captured legacy table into a modern, themed React component:

typescript
// Generated by Replay AI Automation Suite
import React from 'react';
import { useTable } from '@/components/ui/table-provider';
import { LegacyDataMapper } from '@/utils/legacy-bridge';

interface ClaimsTableProps {
  rawCaptureData: any[];
}

export const ClaimsTable: React.FC<ClaimsTableProps> = ({ rawCaptureData }) => {
  // Replay identified this as a 'DataGrid' pattern from the legacy UI
  const formattedData = LegacyDataMapper.transform(rawCaptureData);

  return (
    <div className="rounded-md border bg-card shadow-sm">
      <Table>
        <TableHeader>
          <TableRow>
            <TableHead>Policy ID</TableHead>
            <TableHead>Status</TableHead>
            <TableHead className="text-right">Amount</TableHead>
          </TableRow>
        </TableHeader>
        <TableBody>
          {formattedData.map((row) => (
            <TableRow key={row.id}>
              <TableCell className="font-medium">{row.policyId}</TableCell>
              <TableCell>{row.status}</TableCell>
              <TableCell className="text-right">{row.amount}</TableCell>
            </TableRow>
          ))}
        </TableBody>
      </Table>
    </div>
  );
};

This code isn't just a "guess." It is a reflection of the actual behavioral state captured during the recording session. By generating standardized code, visual behavioral capture eliminates the "spaghetti code" that typically results from manual rewrites where developers try to "improve" logic they don't fully understand.

---

The Role of AI in Reverse Engineering Architecture#

Legacy systems often hide complex state machines. A single screen in a mainframe emulator might have 50 different "modes" based on hidden variables. A human SME might only remember the five most common modes.

Replay’s AI Automation Suite analyzes recordings to find the "edge cases." It identifies the error states, the loading transitions, and the permission-based UI changes that SMEs often forget to mention. This is where the 70% time savings comes from. Instead of discovering a missing feature 12 months into a rewrite, you discover it in the first week during the Visual Reverse Engineering phase.

Implementing a Component Library from Captures#

Once the behaviors are captured, Replay organizes them into Blueprints. These are the functional templates for your new architecture. Instead of building components in isolation, you are building them based on proven user workflows.

typescript
// Example of a Blueprint-generated Layout Component
// This captures the 'Flow' of a legacy sidebar navigation
import { Sidebar, NavItem } from '@/components/design-system';

export const LegacyNavigationBridge = () => {
  const flows = [
    { label: 'Dashboard', path: '/dashboard', icon: 'LayoutDashboard' },
    { label: 'Claims Processing', path: '/claims', icon: 'FileText' },
    { label: 'User Management', path: '/users', icon: 'Users' },
  ];

  return (
    <Sidebar>
      {flows.map((flow) => (
        <NavItem 
          key={flow.path} 
          href={flow.path} 
          icon={flow.icon}
          // Behavioral capture identified that this transition 
          // requires a specific state-clearance in the legacy DB
          onClick={() => console.log(`Triggering legacy sync for ${flow.label}`)}
        >
          {flow.label}
        </NavItem>
      ))}
    </Sidebar>
  );
};

By automating this, visual behavioral capture eliminates the risk of "feature drift," where the new system fails to perform the basic tasks the old system handled effortlessly.

---

Industry-Specific Impact: Regulated Environments#

In sectors like Financial Services, Healthcare, and Government, the SME problem is compounded by compliance. You cannot simply "guess" how a healthcare portal handles HIPAA-protected data layouts.

Replay is built for these high-stakes environments. With SOC2 compliance and HIPAA-ready configurations, it allows organizations to capture workflows on-premise or in secure clouds. In these industries, visual behavioral capture eliminates the security risk of third-party consultants poking around in legacy source code. Instead, the "Video-to-code" process happens within a controlled environment, producing clean, audited React code.

According to Replay's analysis, manufacturing and telecom firms have seen the highest ROI by using visual capture to document "Headless" legacy systems—where the UI is the only way to understand the underlying logic. You can read more about Design System Extraction to see how these visual elements are categorized.

---

Overcoming the "70% Failure" Statistic#

Why do 70% of legacy rewrites fail?

1. •Scope Creep: Trying to fix the business while fixing the code.
2. •Knowledge Loss: SMEs leaving mid-project.
3. •Manual Errors: Developers misinterpreting legacy UI logic.

Visual behavioral capture eliminates these three pillars of failure.

• •It defines the scope by showing exactly what users do.
• •It preserves knowledge by digitizing the SME's actions.
• •It removes manual error by generating code directly from observed behavior.

Instead of an 18-month "Big Bang" rewrite, Replay enables a phased approach. You record a workflow, generate the code, and deploy that specific module. This is how you turn a two-year project into a series of two-week wins.

---

Frequently Asked Questions#

Does visual behavioral capture require access to the legacy source code?#

No. One of the primary advantages is that visual behavioral capture eliminates the need for original source code access. It works by analyzing the rendered UI and user interactions, making it ideal for systems where the source code is lost, obfuscated, or written in obsolete languages like COBOL or PowerBuilder.

How does Replay handle complex business logic that isn't visible on the screen?#

While Replay captures the "Visual Behavior," it also maps the data inputs and outputs associated with those visuals. By documenting the "Flows," it creates a functional map that developers can use to hook into existing APIs or database procedures. It provides the "skeleton" and "skin" of the application, allowing developers to focus 100% of their energy on the "brains" (the backend logic).

Is the generated React code maintainable?#

Yes. Unlike "low-code" platforms that output unreadable "junk" code, Replay generates structured, documented TypeScript and React components. These components follow modern best practices and are designed to be integrated into your existing CI/CD pipelines and Design Systems.

What industries benefit most from eliminating SME dependency?#

Highly regulated industries like Insurance, Banking, and Government benefit most because their SMEs are often nearing retirement and their systems are mission-critical. In these environments, visual behavioral capture eliminates the existential risk of losing operational knowledge.

---

The Future of Enterprise Architecture#

We are moving into an era where "Code as Documentation" is no longer a dream but a requirement. The $3.6 trillion technical debt bubble will not be solved by hiring more developers to manually transcribe old systems. It will be solved by Visual Reverse Engineering.

By shifting to a behavioral capture model, enterprise architects can finally stop acting as historians and start acting as builders. Visual behavioral capture eliminates the baggage of the past, allowing you to extract the value of legacy systems without being held hostage by their complexity.

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay