The CFO's Modernization Checklist: Evaluating 18-Month Rewrites vs. 3-Week Extractions

The average enterprise rewrite takes 18 months and has a 70% chance of failure. For a CFO, that is not a strategic initiative; it is a high-risk liability. Every month your engineering team spends "digging" through legacy code is a month they aren't shipping features that drive revenue. With global technical debt ballooning to $3.6 trillion, the traditional "rip and replace" model has proven itself to be a fiscal black hole.

TL;DR: Modernizing legacy systems no longer requires a multi-year "Big Bang" rewrite; visual reverse engineering allows firms to extract documented, production-ready code from existing workflows in weeks, reducing timelines by 70%.

The $5 Million "Archaeology" Tax#

Most enterprise modernization projects stall because they begin with "software archaeology." When 67% of legacy systems lack up-to-date documentation, your most expensive engineering assets spend 60% of their time just trying to understand what the current system actually does.

They are reading 15-year-old Java, hunting for business logic buried in stored procedures, and guessing at API contracts. This manual discovery process costs roughly 40 hours per screen. In a typical 100-screen financial services application, you are looking at 4,000 hours of manual labor before a single line of modern code is even written.

The Failure of the "Big Bang" Rewrite#

The "Big Bang" approach assumes you can freeze the world for 18-24 months while you rebuild. In reality, the business requirements evolve, the market shifts, and by the time the "new" system is ready, it’s already legacy. This is why 70% of these projects exceed their budgets or fail entirely.

The Shift: Understanding Over Rewriting#

The future of modernization isn't rewriting from scratch—it's understanding what you already have and extracting it. Replay shifts the paradigm from manual code analysis to Visual Reverse Engineering. By using video as the source of truth, Replay records real user workflows and automatically generates documented React components, API contracts, and E2E tests.

Instead of a developer spending a week documenting a complex insurance claims form, they record the workflow in 10 minutes. Replay's AI Automation Suite then handles the heavy lifting of generating the modern equivalent.

💰 ROI Insight: Manual modernization costs average $5,000–$8,000 per screen in labor. Replay reduces this to under $800 by cutting the time-per-screen from 40 hours to 4 hours.

The CFO’s Evaluation Framework#

When a VP of Engineering asks for a $2M budget for a "modernization project," the CFO should demand a breakdown of the extraction-to-rewrite ratio. If the plan is 100% rewrite, the risk is unacceptably high.

1. Documentation Without Archaeology#

If the team cannot produce a technical debt audit and a full map of existing flows within 30 days, the project is flying blind. Replay provides a "Library" (Design System) and "Flows" (Architecture) automatically, turning a black box into a documented codebase before the first sprint ends.

2. Preserving Business Logic#

The greatest risk in modernization is losing the "hidden" business logic—the edge cases handled by the legacy system that no one remembers writing. Visual extraction captures these behaviors as they happen in the live environment.

typescript
// Example: React component generated by Replay from a legacy workflow
// Business logic is preserved and modularized for the modern stack.

import React, { useState, useEffect } from 'react';
import { Button, Input, Alert } from '@/components/ui';

export function LegacyClaimsProcessor({ claimId }: { claimId: string }) {
  const [data, setData] = useState<any>(null);
  const [loading, setLoading] = useState(true);

  // Replay extracted this API contract from observed network traffic
  async function handleValidation(values: any) {
    const response = await fetch(`/api/v1/claims/${claimId}/validate`, {
      method: 'POST',
      body: JSON.stringify(values),
    });
    return response.json();
  }

  return (
    <div className="p-6 bg-white rounded-lg shadow">
      <h2 className="text-xl font-bold mb-4">Extracted Claims Workflow</h2>
      {/* Modernized UI components mapped from legacy layout */}
      <form onSubmit={handleValidation}>
        <Input name="policyNumber" label="Policy Number" defaultValue={data?.policy} />
        <Button type="submit">Process Claim</Button>
      </form>
    </div>
  );
}

3. Automated Testing Parity#

A rewrite is only successful if the new system produces the same outcomes as the old one. Replay generates E2E tests based on the recorded video workflows, ensuring that the modernized version maintains 100% functional parity with the legacy system.

⚠️ Warning: Any modernization plan that doesn't include automated test generation from existing workflows will inevitably result in regression bugs that haunt the project for months post-launch.

Step-by-Step: The 3-Week Extraction Path#

Modernization via Replay follows a streamlined, data-driven path that eliminates the "discovery" phase of traditional projects.

Step 1: Visual Recording & Assessment#

Users or QA testers record standard operating procedures within the legacy application. Replay captures the DOM changes, network requests, and state transitions. This creates a "Source of Truth" that is far more accurate than any 50-page requirements document.

Step 2: Architecture Mapping (Flows)#

The platform analyzes the recordings to map out the application's architecture. It identifies common components, shared data structures, and API dependencies. This replaces months of manual architectural review.

Step 3: Automated Extraction & Blueprinting#

Using the "Blueprints" editor, engineers refine the AI-generated React components. The system generates:

• •Clean React/TypeScript code
• •OpenAPI/Swagger contracts
• •Playwright/Cypress E2E tests
• •Technical Debt Audits

Step 4: Integration & Deployment#

Because the code is generated to match your organization's specific design system and coding standards, it can be integrated into the new environment immediately.

💡 Pro Tip: Focus your first 3-week "sprint" on the most complex, least-documented module. If you can extract and modernize that, the rest of the application is a downhill run.

Why Regulated Industries Are Moving Away from Rewrites#

In sectors like Financial Services, Healthcare, and Government, the cost of a failed rewrite isn't just financial—it’s regulatory.

• •Security: Manual rewrites often introduce new security vulnerabilities. Replay’s extraction process maintains the integrity of the original business logic while moving it to a modern, more secure framework.
• •Compliance: Replay is built for regulated environments, offering SOC2 compliance, HIPAA-readiness, and the ability to run On-Premise. This ensures that sensitive data never leaves your secure perimeter during the reverse engineering process.
• •Audit Trails: By using video as the source of truth, you have a perfect audit trail of why the new system was built the way it was.

yaml
# Replay Generated API Contract (OpenAPI 3.0)
# Extracted from observed legacy traffic in a Healthcare environment
openapi: 3.0.0
info:
  title: Legacy Patient Portal API
  version: 1.0.0
paths:
  /patient/records/{id}:
    get:
      summary: Extracted Patient Record Fetch
      parameters:
        - name: id
          in: path
          required: true
          schema:
            type: string
      responses:
        '200':
          description: Successful extraction of legacy data structure
          content:
            application/json:
              schema:
                $ref: '#/components/schemas/PatientRecord'

The Opportunity Cost of Delay#

Every year you delay modernization, your maintenance costs increase by 10-15%. You are paying a "legacy tax" on every new feature you try to build. If your engineering team is currently quoting an 18-month timeline, you are effectively deciding to stop innovating until late next year.

Replay allows you to modernize in parallel with your current roadmap. By saving 70% of the time typically spent on discovery and coding, you free up your team to focus on high-value features that differentiate your business in the market.

📝 Note: The "Strangler Fig" pattern is often cited as a lower-risk alternative to Big Bang rewrites. While better, it still relies on manual code understanding. Replay accelerates the Strangler Fig pattern by automating the discovery of the "edges" that need to be replaced.

Frequently Asked Questions#

How long does legacy extraction take?#

While a full enterprise suite may take several months to fully migrate, individual complex screens and their associated logic are typically extracted, documented, and modernized in 4 hours or less. A pilot project covering a core workflow usually takes 2-3 weeks from setup to code delivery.

What about business logic preservation?#

This is Replay's core strength. By recording the actual execution of the software, we capture how the system actually behaves, not just how the code is written. Our AI Automation Suite identifies the underlying logic patterns and replicates them in clean, modern TypeScript, ensuring functional parity.

Does Replay require access to our source code?#

No. Replay performs Visual Reverse Engineering. We record the application in its running state (web-based). This is particularly valuable for legacy systems where the original source code is messy, undocumented, or even lost, but the application is still running in production.

Which frameworks does Replay support?#

Replay currently generates high-quality React components and TypeScript logic. It can extract from any web-based legacy system, including those built on old versions of Angular, jQuery, ASP.NET, Java Server Faces (JSF), or even mainframe emulators running in a browser.

---

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.