Strangler Fig vs Video Extraction: Choosing the Right Modernization Strategy

Legacy modernization is where engineering careers go to die. Every year, enterprises pour billions into "Big Bang" rewrites that never see the light of day. Statistics from the Standish Group and McKinsey consistently show that 70% of legacy rewrites fail or exceed their timeline, often by years. With a global technical debt mountain reaching $3.6 trillion, the industry has reached a breaking point.

The traditional "safe" alternative—the Strangler Fig pattern—is no longer fast enough for the modern market. While it mitigates risk, it introduces massive operational complexity and often stretches 18-month timelines into three-year slogs.

There is a third path: Visual Reverse Engineering. By using video as the source of truth, platforms like Replay are turning the "archaeology" of legacy systems into a streamlined extraction process, reducing the time spent per screen from 40 hours to just 4.

TL;DR: While the Strangler Fig pattern provides a safe migration path through incremental replacement, Visual Reverse Engineering (via Replay) bypasses the "documentation archaeology" phase, reducing modernization timelines by 70% by extracting UI and logic directly from user workflows.

The Modernization Matrix: Strangler Fig vs. Video Extraction#

Choosing a strategy requires understanding the trade-offs between speed, risk, and the "Black Box" problem. Most legacy systems suffer from a 67% lack of documentation, meaning your engineers spend more time reading old COBOL or jQuery spaghetti than they do writing new React components.

The Strangler Fig: The "Safe" Slow Burn#

The Strangler Fig pattern, popularized by Martin Fowler, involves placing a proxy or "interceptor" in front of the legacy system. You build new features in the modern stack and slowly route traffic away from the monolith.

The Technical Overhead of Strangler Fig#

To implement this, you typically start with an API Gateway or a Reverse Proxy. Here is a simplified example of a Node.js/Express proxy routing traffic between a legacy PHP monolith and a modern NestJS microservice:

typescript
// Example: Strangler Fig Proxy Implementation
import express from 'express';
import { createProxyMiddleware } from 'http-proxy-middleware';

const app = express();

// Modernized Auth Service
app.use('/api/v2/auth', createProxyMiddleware({ 
  target: 'http://new-auth-service:3000', 
  changeOrigin: true 
}));

// Legacy Monolith (The "Strangled" System)
app.use('/', createProxyMiddleware({ 
  target: 'http://legacy-monolith:8080', 
  changeOrigin: true 
}));

app.listen(80);

While this works, it creates a "Double Maintenance" tax. Your team must maintain the proxy, handle session sharing between two disparate environments, and deal with the latency of multiple hops. In regulated environments like Financial Services or Healthcare, the security implications of session synchronization across two stacks are a nightmare.

⚠️ Warning: The Strangler Fig pattern often leads to "Zombie Legacy" systems where 90% of the app is modernized, but the last 10% of core business logic is too complex to move, forcing you to maintain both stacks indefinitely.

Video Extraction: The Replay Paradigm#

The fundamental flaw in traditional modernization is the "Discovery Phase." Engineers spend months interviewing users and digging through undocumented code to understand business rules.

Replay flips this script. Instead of reading code, you record the application in use. Replay’s engine performs Visual Reverse Engineering, capturing the DOM state, network calls, and user interactions to generate documented React components and API contracts automatically.

From Video to Production-Ready Code#

When you record a workflow in Replay, the platform doesn't just take a screenshot. It analyzes the underlying data structures. Here is an example of the type of clean, modular React code Replay generates from a legacy insurance claim form:

tsx
// Generated via Replay Blueprints
import React, { useState, useEffect } from 'react';
import { Button, Input, Card } from '@/components/ui'; // From your Replay Library
import { useLegacyBridge } from '@/hooks/useLegacyBridge';

interface ClaimData {
  policyId: string;
  incidentDate: string;
  description: string;
}

export const ModernizedClaimForm: React.FC = () => {
  const [formData, setFormData] = useState<ClaimData>({
    policyId: '',
    incidentDate: '',
    description: ''
  });

  // Replay automatically identifies the legacy API endpoint from the recording
  const { submitClaim, isLoading } = useLegacyBridge('/api/legacy/claims/submit');

  const handleSubmit = async () => {
    const success = await submitClaim(formData);
    if (success) {
      console.log('✅ Logic preserved from legacy workflow');
    }
  };

  return (
    <Card title="Submit Insurance Claim">
      <Input 
        label="Policy Number" 
        value={formData.policyId} 
        onChange={(v) => setFormData({...formData, policyId: v})} 
      />
      {/* ... additional fields ... */}
      <Button onClick={handleSubmit} loading={isLoading}>
        Submit Migration
      </Button>
    </Card>
  );
};

💰 ROI Insight: Manual modernization of a single enterprise screen (Discovery + Design + Code + Test) averages 40 hours. Replay reduces this to 4 hours by automating the discovery and scaffolding phases.

The 4-Step Extraction Workflow#

Modernizing with Replay follows a structured path that eliminates the "Black Box" risk.

Step 1: Record Workflows#

Users or QA engineers record real-world usage of the legacy system. This captures the "Source of Truth"—not what the documentation says the app does, but what it actually does. This is critical for regulated industries like Telecom or Government where edge cases are buried in decades of patches.

Step 2: Library Mapping#

Replay’s Library feature identifies UI patterns. If your legacy app uses a specific table structure, Replay maps it to your modern Design System. This ensures visual consistency without manual CSS hacking.

Step 3: Blueprint Generation#

The Blueprints editor allows architects to review the extracted logic. Replay generates:

• •API Contracts: Swagger/OpenAPI specs based on observed network traffic.
• •State Models: How data flows through the form.
• •E2E Tests: Automatically generated Playwright or Cypress scripts that mirror the recorded session.

Step 4: Technical Debt Audit#

Before pushing to production, Replay provides a Technical Debt Audit. It identifies redundant logic and deprecated API calls that were present in the legacy system but aren't needed in the modern architecture.

💡 Pro Tip: Use Replay’s "Flows" feature to map out the entire application architecture visually. This replaces the "Archaeology" phase with a real-time architectural map.

Why Strangler Fig Fails in Regulated Environments#

In sectors like Healthcare (HIPAA) and Finance (SOC2), the Strangler Fig’s incremental approach often hits a wall regarding data integrity.

1. •Distributed Transactions: Trying to maintain ACID compliance between a legacy SQL Server database and a modern NoSQL cluster during a "strangle" is notoriously difficult.
2. •Security Surface Area: Every day you run two systems is a day you have double the attack surface.
3. •On-Premise Constraints: Many legacy systems are air-gapped. Replay offers On-Premise deployment, allowing for visual extraction without data ever leaving your secure perimeter.

Comparing the Cost of Knowledge#

The hidden killer of enterprise budgets is Cognitive Load. When an architect has to understand a 20-year-old system, they aren't building value; they are performing forensic science.

• •Strangler Fig: Requires deep knowledge of the legacy system to build the proxy and intercept calls correctly.
• •Video Extraction: Requires zero knowledge of the legacy source code. If you can run the application, you can extract it.

📝 Note: Replay is not just a "no-code" tool. It is an AI-powered engineering workbench. It generates high-quality TypeScript that your developers will actually want to own and maintain.

Frequently Asked Questions#

How long does legacy extraction take with Replay?#

While a traditional Strangler Fig approach takes 12-18 months for a mid-sized enterprise app, Replay typically completes the extraction and documentation phase in 2 to 8 weeks. The actual code generation for a complex screen takes hours, not days.

Does Replay support legacy systems like Mainframes or Delphi?#

Yes. Because Replay uses Visual Reverse Engineering, it is tech-stack agnostic. If the application has a UI (Web, Citrix, Desktop, or Terminal Emulator), Replay can record the workflow and extract the logic into modern React components.

What about business logic that isn't visible on the UI?#

Replay captures the network layer and state transitions. While it perfectly recreates the "Frontend" and "Orchestration" layers, deep backend business logic (like a complex COBOL calculation) is documented via API Contracts. You can then choose to keep the legacy backend as a service or rewrite it using the generated documentation as a spec.

How does this handle SOC2 and HIPAA compliance?#

Replay is built for regulated industries. We offer SOC2 compliance, HIPAA-ready data handling, and the ability to run the entire platform On-Premise. No code or sensitive user data ever needs to touch the cloud.

Can we use Replay alongside a Strangler Fig approach?#

Absolutely. Many of our clients use Replay to "accelerate" the Strangler Fig. They use Replay to rapidly document and build the modern UI/Frontend, while using a proxy to handle the backend migration over a longer period.

---

The Path Forward: Understanding Over Rewriting#

The future of Enterprise Architecture isn't in the "Big Bang." It’s in the ability to rapidly understand, document, and extract value from existing systems. $3.6 trillion in technical debt cannot be solved by manual labor alone. It requires automation that respects the complexity of legacy logic while providing a clean break to modern frameworks.

Stop digging through the "Black Box." Start recording.

---

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.