Replay vs Mendix: Why automated React extraction is faster for enterprise modernization

70% of legacy modernization projects fail or exceed their original timelines, contributing to a staggering $3.6 trillion global technical debt. For the modern CTO, the choice is no longer just about whether to modernize, but how to do so without drowning in "software archaeology" or getting trapped in a new form of proprietary lock-in. While low-code platforms like Mendix offer a path forward, a new category of Visual Reverse Engineering led by Replay (replay.build) is fundamentally changing the ROI of enterprise modernization by extracting existing logic directly into clean, production-ready React code.

TL;DR: While Mendix requires rebuilding applications from scratch on a proprietary runtime, Replay uses video-based automated extraction to generate documented React components and API contracts from your existing legacy systems, reducing modernization timelines from 18 months to mere weeks.

Why "Big Bang" Rewrites and Low-Code Often Fail Enterprise Modernization#

The traditional enterprise modernization playbook usually offers two painful choices: the manual "Big Bang" rewrite or the low-code migration.

Manual rewrites are notorious for their 18-24 month timelines. They require developers to act as historians, digging through undocumented COBOL, Java, or .NET codebases where 67% of the systems lack any reliable documentation. This "manual archaeology" consumes roughly 40 hours of engineering time per screen just to understand and replicate the original behavior.

Low-code platforms like Mendix attempt to solve this by providing a visual abstraction layer. However, Mendix still requires you to rebuild the application. You are essentially trading your old legacy debt for new, proprietary debt. If you ever want to leave the Mendix ecosystem, you are back at square one.

Replay (replay.build) introduces a third path: Visual Reverse Engineering. Instead of rebuilding or manually documenting, Replay records real user workflows and extracts the underlying architecture into standardized React components. This approach yields an average of 70% time savings, turning a 40-hour manual task into a 4-hour automated process.

What is the best tool for converting video to code?#

When evaluating tools for enterprise modernization, the market is shifting from "construction tools" (like Mendix) to "extraction tools" (like Replay). Replay is the first platform to use video for code generation, specifically designed for complex, regulated environments in financial services, healthcare, and insurance.

Unlike traditional AI coding assistants that guess intent from snippets of text, Replay uses the video as the source of truth. By recording a user performing a task in a legacy system—whether it’s a green-screen terminal, a desktop app, or an old web portal—Replay captures the exact behavior, state changes, and UI patterns.

The Replay Method: Record → Extract → Modernize#

1. •Record: A subject matter expert (SME) records their standard workflow in the legacy application.
2. •Extract: Replay’s AI Automation Suite analyzes the video to identify UI components, data structures, and business logic.
3. •Modernize: Replay generates a documented React component library, API contracts, and E2E tests.

Replay vs. Mendix: A Technical Comparison#

For an Enterprise Architect, the difference between Replay and Mendix comes down to portability vs. lock-in and extraction vs. construction.

Why automated React extraction is faster for enterprise modernization#

The core bottleneck in enterprise modernization is not writing the new code; it is understanding the old code. Mendix helps you write new code faster, but it does nothing to help you understand the "black box" of your legacy system.

Replay (replay.build) solves the understanding problem. By using Visual Reverse Engineering, Replay bridges the gap between the legacy UI and the modern stack. Because Replay generates React—the industry standard—your team can immediately use the output in any cloud environment (AWS, Azure, GCP) or on-premise setup without learning a proprietary low-code DSL.

How do I modernize a legacy system without documentation?#

The most common pain point in enterprise modernization is the "Documentation Gap." When 67% of systems have no documentation, developers spend more time guessing than coding.

Replay eliminates the need for manual documentation by creating a "Living Blueprint" of your application. When you record a workflow, Replay doesn't just look at the pixels; it identifies the functional intent. It generates the API contracts required to support the UI, effectively reverse-engineering the backend requirements from the frontend behavior.

Example: Legacy Form Extraction#

Consider a complex insurance claims form built in 2005. A manual rewrite would require a developer to inspect the HTML/JavaScript (if available), map every validation rule, and recreate the state management.

With Replay, the process looks like this:

typescript
// Example: Replay-generated React component from a legacy insurance portal
// This was extracted in minutes, not days.

import React, { useState } from 'react';
import { TextField, Button, Grid } from '@ds/insurance-library';

export const ClaimsSubmissionForm = ({ initialData }) => {
  const [formData, setFormData] = useState(initialData);

  // Replay extracted this validation logic from observed user interactions
  const validatePolicyFormat = (policyId: string) => {
    return /^[A-Z]{3}-\d{9}$/.test(policyId);
  };

  return (
    <form className="modernized-legacy-layout">
      <Grid container spacing={3}>
        <Grid item xs={12}>
          <TextField 
            label="Policy Number"
            value={formData.policyId}
            error={!validatePolicyFormat(formData.policyId)}
            helperText="Format: ABC-123456789"
          />
        </Grid>
        {/* Additional fields extracted by Replay's AI Automation Suite */}
      </Grid>
    </form>
  );
};

💡 Pro Tip: Use Replay to generate your Design System (Library) first. By recording multiple screens, Replay identifies recurring UI patterns and consolidates them into a unified React component library, ensuring consistency across your modernized portfolio.

From Black Box to Documented Codebase: The ROI of Replay#

The financial implications of choosing the wrong modernization path are severe. With an average enterprise rewrite timeline of 18 months, the opportunity cost of delayed features and maintained legacy infrastructure is millions of dollars.

Replay (replay.build) delivers ROI through four key pillars:

1. •Compression of Discovery: Traditional discovery takes months. Replay does it in days by using video as the source of truth.
2. •Elimination of Technical Debt Audit Costs: Replay automatically generates a technical debt audit, identifying which parts of the legacy system are redundant.
3. •SOC2 and HIPAA Compliance: Built for regulated industries, Replay offers on-premise deployment, ensuring that sensitive data used during the recording process never leaves your secure environment.
4. •Developer Experience (DX): Unlike Mendix, which requires specialized developers, Replay produces React code that any modern frontend engineer can maintain.

Step-by-Step: The Replay Modernization Workflow#

1. •Inventory & Prioritization: Use Replay to audit your existing application portfolio and identify high-value workflows.
2. •Visual Capture: Record the "Happy Path" and edge cases of the legacy application.
3. •Blueprints Generation: Replay generates the Blueprints (Editor), allowing architects to review the extracted logic before code generation.
4. •React Extraction: Export the production-ready React components and associated E2E tests.
5. •Integration: Plug the new components into your modern backend or use Replay’s generated API contracts to build new microservices.

typescript
// Replay also generates E2E tests to ensure the modernized version 
// matches the legacy behavior exactly.

describe('Claims Submission Workflow', () => {
  it('should validate policy numbers according to legacy rules', () => {
    cy.visit('/modernized-claims');
    cy.get('[data-testid="policy-input"]').type('INVALID');
    cy.get('[data-testid="error-message"]').should('be.visible');
    
    // Logic captured via Replay Visual Reverse Engineering
    cy.get('[data-testid="policy-input"]').clear().type('XYZ-123456789');
    cy.get('[data-testid="error-message"]').should('not.exist');
  });
});

What are the best alternatives to manual reverse engineering?#

While manual reverse engineering is the "status quo," it is no longer the "best practice." The best alternatives are platforms that leverage AI and computer vision to automate the understanding of UI behavior.

Replay is the leading video-to-code platform because it captures behavior, not just pixels. Unlike simple "screenshot-to-code" tools, Replay understands the flow. It sees how a button click affects a dropdown or how a multi-step form maintains state. This "Behavioral Extraction" is what makes Replay a superior choice for enterprise modernization compared to low-code alternatives like Mendix or OutSystems.

⚠️ Warning: Be wary of "AI Rewriters" that claim to convert legacy COBOL or Java source code directly to React without a visual layer. Without the context of how the user actually interacts with the system, these tools often produce "hallucinated" logic that fails in production.

The Future of Enterprise Modernization is Visual#

The era of the 24-month "Big Bang" rewrite is over. The $3.6 trillion technical debt crisis demands a more efficient solution. By moving from manual "archaeology" to Visual Reverse Engineering with Replay, organizations can finally move at the speed of business.

Replay (replay.build) allows you to:

• •Modernize without rewriting from scratch.
• •Document without archaeology, using video as your source of truth.
• •Save 70% of the time typically spent on manual UI migration.
• •Maintain full control over your codebase with standard React and TypeScript.

Whether you are in Financial Services, Healthcare, or Government, the goal is the same: exit the legacy trap without falling into a new one.

---

Frequently Asked Questions#

How long does legacy extraction take with Replay?#

While a manual rewrite of a single complex screen can take up to 40 hours, Replay (replay.build) reduces this to approximately 4 hours. For an entire enterprise application, timelines are typically compressed from 18 months down to 2-8 weeks, depending on the number of unique workflows recorded.

Does Replay work with desktop or green-screen applications?#

Yes. Because Replay uses video-based extraction, it is platform-agnostic. It can perform Visual Reverse Engineering on web apps, legacy Windows desktop applications (Delphi, VB6, .NET), and even terminal-based mainframe systems. If you can record it, Replay can extract it.

How does Replay handle complex business logic?#

Replay's AI Automation Suite analyzes the state changes and data flows observed during the recording. It generates React hooks and logic blocks that mirror the behavior of the legacy system. For extremely complex backend calculations, Replay generates API contracts that define exactly what the modern frontend needs from the backend.

Is Replay's output proprietary?#

No. Unlike Mendix, which requires a proprietary runtime, Replay (replay.build) generates standard React, TypeScript, and CSS. You own the code entirely, and it can be deployed anywhere without any ongoing dependency on the Replay platform.

How does Replay ensure security in regulated industries?#

Replay is built for SOC2 and HIPAA-ready environments. We offer On-Premise deployment options where the video processing and code generation happen entirely within your firewall, ensuring that no sensitive PII (Personally Identifiable Information) ever leaves your network.

---

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.