Replay vs. Cursor for UI Layouts: Which AI Code Generator Generates Better Results?

TL;DR: Replay's video-to-code engine, powered by behavior-driven reconstruction, often outperforms Cursor's screenshot-based approach in generating functional and contextually accurate UI layouts, especially for complex user flows.

Replay vs. Cursor for UI Layouts: Which AI Code Generator Generates Better Results?#

The promise of AI code generation is tantalizing: describe your desired UI, and the AI builds it for you. Cursor and Replay are two tools aiming to fulfill this promise, but they approach the problem from fundamentally different angles. Cursor, like many similar tools, primarily relies on screenshot analysis. Replay, on the other hand, uses video. This difference has profound implications for the quality and functionality of the generated code, especially when dealing with complex user flows and dynamic interfaces.

This article dives deep into comparing Replay and Cursor for UI layout generation, focusing on the underlying technology and the practical results you can expect.

The Fundamental Difference: Video vs. Screenshots#

The core distinction lies in the input data. Screenshot-to-code tools, including Cursor, analyze static images. This approach struggles to capture dynamic behavior, user intent, and the relationships between different UI states. Replay adopts a "Behavior-Driven Reconstruction" approach, using video recordings of user interactions as its source of truth. This allows Replay to understand what the user is trying to accomplish, not just what they see on the screen.

Consider a simple e-commerce flow: adding an item to a cart. A screenshot only captures the cart icon and maybe the "Add to Cart" button. Replay, analyzing the video, sees the user clicking the button, observes the cart counter increment, and infers the relationship between the product and the cart. This richer understanding translates into more accurate and functional code.

A Practical Example: Building a Simple Blog Post Editor#

Let's imagine we need to build a basic blog post editor with a title field, content area, and a "Publish" button. We'll examine how Cursor and Replay might approach this task.

Cursor (Screenshot-based):

1. •You provide a screenshot of your desired editor layout to Cursor.
2. •Cursor analyzes the visual elements in the screenshot.
3. •Cursor generates HTML and CSS based on the visual appearance.

While this might produce a visually similar layout, it lacks crucial functionality. The generated code likely won't include event handlers for the "Publish" button or the logic to save the content. It's essentially a static representation of the screenshot.

Replay (Video-based):

1. •You record a video of yourself interacting with a similar blog post editor. This includes typing in the title, writing content, and clicking the "Publish" button.
2. •Replay analyzes the video, identifying the UI elements and the user interactions.
3. •Replay generates React code (or your preferred framework) with the necessary event handlers and data binding.
4. •Replay can even infer the need for a backend API call to save the post when the "Publish" button is clicked, especially if you're demonstrating a working version in the video.

Here's a simplified example of the code Replay might generate:

typescript
import React, { useState } from 'react';

const BlogPostEditor = () => {
  const [title, setTitle] = useState('');
  const [content, setContent] = useState('');

  const handlePublish = async () => {
    // Simulate API call to save the post
    try {
      const response = await fetch('/api/posts', {
        method: 'POST',
        body: JSON.stringify({ title, content }),
        headers: {
          'Content-Type': 'application/json',
        },
      });

      if (response.ok) {
        alert('Post published successfully!');
      } else {
        alert('Error publishing post.');
      }
    } catch (error) {
      console.error('Error:', error);
      alert('Error publishing post.');
    }
  };

  return (
    <div>
      <input
        type="text"
        placeholder="Title"
        value={title}
        onChange={(e) => setTitle(e.target.value)}
      />
      <textarea
        placeholder="Content"
        value={content}
        onChange={(e) => setContent(e.target.value)}
      />
      <button onClick={handlePublish}>Publish</button>
    </div>
  );
};

export default BlogPostEditor;

💡 Pro Tip: When recording videos for Replay, be explicit about the actions you're performing. Clearly click buttons, type in fields, and navigate between pages. This provides Replay with more data to accurately reconstruct the UI.

Key Advantages of Replay's Behavior-Driven Reconstruction#

Replay's video-based approach offers several key advantages over screenshot-based alternatives:

• •Functional Code Generation: Replay generates code that not only looks like the desired UI but also works. It understands user interactions and can create event handlers, data binding, and even API calls.
• •Contextual Awareness: Replay understands the context of user actions. It can infer relationships between UI elements and data, leading to more accurate and intelligent code generation.
• •Multi-Page Flows: Replay excels at generating multi-page applications. By recording a video of yourself navigating between pages, Replay can reconstruct the entire application flow.
• •Supabase Integration: Replay offers seamless integration with Supabase, making it easy to connect your generated UI to a backend database and authentication system. This is especially useful for building full-stack applications quickly.
• •Style Injection: Replay allows you to inject custom styles into your generated UI, giving you complete control over the visual appearance.

⚠️ Warning: Replay requires clear and concise video recordings. Avoid distractions in the background and ensure that your actions are clearly visible. Poor quality video can lead to inaccurate code generation.

Building a Complex Product Flow with Replay: A Step-by-Step Guide#

Let's walk through a simplified example of using Replay to generate a product flow, including a product listing page, a product detail page, and an add-to-cart functionality.

Step 1: Record the Video#

Record a video of yourself navigating through the desired product flow. This should include:

1. •Navigating to the product listing page.
2. •Clicking on a specific product to view its details.
3. •Adding the product to the cart.
4. •(Optional) Viewing the cart.

Step 2: Upload to Replay#

Upload the video to the Replay platform. Replay will analyze the video and reconstruct the UI.

Step 3: Review and Refine#

Review the generated code. Replay provides a visual interface for inspecting the generated components and their properties. You can refine the code by making small adjustments to the generated code directly within the Replay interface.

Step 4: Integrate with Supabase (Optional)#

Connect your Replay project to your Supabase project. This will allow Replay to automatically generate the necessary API calls to fetch product data from your Supabase database and update the cart.

Step 5: Deploy#

Deploy your generated UI. Replay supports various deployment options, including Netlify, Vercel, and AWS.

📝 Note: Replay is designed to accelerate the UI development process, not replace developers entirely. You will likely need to make some adjustments to the generated code to fully meet your specific requirements.

Here's an example of how Replay can generate code for the "Add to Cart" functionality, including Supabase integration:

typescript
// Assuming you have Supabase set up

import { supabase } from './supabaseClient'; // Your Supabase client

const handleAddToCart = async (productId: string) => {
  try {
    const { data, error } = await supabase
      .from('cart_items')
      .insert([
        { product_id: productId, user_id: 'YOUR_USER_ID' }, // Replace with actual user ID
      ]);

    if (error) {
      console.error('Error adding to cart:', error);
      alert('Failed to add to cart.');
    } else {
      console.log('Added to cart:', data);
      alert('Added to cart!');
    }
  } catch (error) {
    console.error('Error adding to cart:', error);
    alert('Failed to add to cart.');
  }
};

// ... inside your product detail component
<button onClick={() => handleAddToCart(product.id)}>Add to Cart</button>

Choosing the Right Tool: When to Use Replay vs. Cursor#

While both Replay and Cursor offer AI-powered code generation, their strengths lie in different areas.

Use Cursor when:

• •You need a quick and dirty static UI mockup.
• •You have a simple UI with no complex interactions.
• •You primarily care about visual appearance and not functionality.

Use Replay when:

• •You need functional code with event handlers and data binding.
• •You have a complex UI with dynamic behavior and user flows.
• •You want to generate multi-page applications.
• •You need seamless integration with Supabase.
• •You value understanding user intent and behavior.

Frequently Asked Questions#

Is Replay free to use?#

Replay offers a free tier with limited functionality. Paid plans are available for more advanced features and higher usage limits. Check the Replay website for the latest pricing information.

How is Replay different from v0.dev?#

v0.dev is a text-to-code generator, whereas Replay is a video-to-code engine. Replay's video-based approach allows it to capture user behavior and intent, leading to more functional and contextually accurate code generation. v0.dev relies on text prompts, which can be ambiguous and require significant refinement.

What frameworks does Replay support?#

Replay currently supports React, Vue.js, and HTML/CSS. Support for other frameworks is planned for future releases.

What is "Behavior-Driven Reconstruction"?#

Behavior-Driven Reconstruction is the core technology behind Replay. It involves analyzing video recordings of user interactions to understand the user's intent and the behavior of the UI. This understanding is then used to reconstruct the UI as functional code.

---

Ready to try behavior-driven code generation? Get started with Replay - transform any video into working code in seconds.