Replay vs. Builder.io for Complex UI Logic: Which AI Code Generator is Better?

TL;DR: Replay excels over Builder.io in generating code for complex UI logic by analyzing video recordings of user behavior, leading to more accurate and functional reconstructions.

The promise of AI code generation is tantalizing: turn ideas into working software faster than ever. But the reality often falls short, especially when dealing with intricate UI interactions and business logic. Two platforms vying for your attention are Replay and Builder.io. While both aim to accelerate development, their approaches and strengths differ significantly. This article dives deep into a head-to-head comparison, focusing on how each handles complex UI logic.

Replay: Behavior-Driven Reconstruction#

Replay takes a unique "behavior-driven reconstruction" approach. Instead of relying on static screenshots or design files, Replay analyzes video recordings of user interactions. This allows it to understand the intent behind the UI, not just the visual representation. By using Gemini's powerful video processing capabilities, Replay can reconstruct multi-page applications, integrate with backend services like Supabase, and even inject custom styles.

Builder.io: Visual Editor with Code Generation#

Builder.io, on the other hand, is primarily a visual editor that allows you to build pages using a drag-and-drop interface. It then generates code based on your visual design. While Builder.io offers flexibility in terms of visual layout, it often struggles with complex interactions and dynamic data handling, requiring significant manual coding to achieve desired functionality.

Key Differences: Understanding the Approaches#

The fundamental difference lies in the input and the underlying understanding of user intent.

Handling Complex UI Logic: A Practical Example#

Let's consider a common scenario: a multi-step onboarding flow with conditional logic based on user input. Imagine a user recording themselves going through the flow.

Builder.io's Approach: Manual Integration#

With Builder.io, you would design each step of the onboarding flow visually. However, implementing the conditional logic (e.g., showing different steps based on user selections) would require writing custom JavaScript code and integrating it with Builder.io's API. This can become cumbersome and error-prone, especially as the complexity of the logic increases.

javascript
// Builder.io - Example of conditional logic (simplified)
builder.on('load', (builderContent) => {
  const userType = builderContent.data.userType;
  if (userType === 'admin') {
    // Show admin-specific steps
    builder.showElement('admin-step-1');
  } else {
    // Show regular user steps
    builder.showElement('user-step-1');
  }
});

This code snippet demonstrates the need for manual JavaScript intervention to handle even simple conditional logic within a Builder.io-created page. The more complex the logic, the more code you need to write and maintain.

Replay's Approach: AI-Powered Reconstruction#

With Replay, you simply record a video of a user completing the onboarding flow, demonstrating all the different paths and interactions. Replay's AI analyzes the video, understands the user's intent at each step, and automatically generates the code for the entire flow, including the conditional logic. This drastically reduces the amount of manual coding required. Replay infers the logic from the demonstrated behavior.

💡 Pro Tip: For best results with Replay, ensure your video recordings are clear and demonstrate all possible user interactions and edge cases.

Diving Deeper: Code Generation Capabilities#

Replay doesn't just generate static HTML. It creates functional code that can be directly integrated into your existing projects. This includes:

• •React Components: Replay generates well-structured React components with proper state management and event handling.
• •API Integrations: If the video demonstrates interactions with backend APIs, Replay can automatically generate the necessary API calls and data handling logic.
• •State Management: Replay can infer and implement state management solutions (e.g., using React's
  text

  useState
  hook or a more complex state management library) based on the user's interactions in the video.

Step-by-Step: Reconstructing a Simple UI with Replay#

Let's walk through a simplified example of how Replay works.

Step 1: Record the Video#

Record a video of yourself interacting with the UI you want to reconstruct. This could be a simple form submission or a more complex multi-page flow.

Step 2: Upload to Replay#

Upload the video to the Replay platform.

Step 3: AI Analysis#

Replay's AI engine analyzes the video, identifying UI elements, user interactions, and underlying logic.

Step 4: Code Generation#

Replay generates the code for the UI, including React components, event handlers, and API integrations (if applicable).

Step 5: Review and Refine#

Review the generated code and make any necessary refinements. Replay provides tools for editing and customizing the code to fit your specific needs.

⚠️ Warning: While Replay strives for accuracy, it's essential to review the generated code to ensure it meets your requirements and adheres to your coding standards.

Supabase Integration: A Powerful Combination#

Replay's seamless integration with Supabase makes it even more powerful. If your video demonstrates interactions with a Supabase database (e.g., creating a new user account), Replay can automatically generate the code to interact with your Supabase instance.

typescript
// Replay-generated code for Supabase user creation
const createUser = async (email: string, password: string) => {
  const { data, error } = await supabase.auth.signUp({
    email: email,
    password: password,
  });

  if (error) {
    console.error("Error creating user:", error);
    return null;
  }

  return data.user;
};

This code snippet showcases how Replay can automatically generate code that interacts with Supabase, simplifying the process of building data-driven applications.

Product Flow Maps: Visualizing User Journeys#

Replay also offers a unique feature called "Product Flow Maps." This visualizes the user's journey through the application, highlighting the different paths and interactions. This can be invaluable for understanding user behavior and identifying areas for improvement.

Style Injection: Maintaining Visual Consistency#

Replay allows you to inject custom styles into the generated code, ensuring that the UI matches your existing design system. This can be done through CSS files, styled components, or other styling solutions.

📝 Note: Style injection ensures visual consistency across your application, maintaining brand identity and a cohesive user experience.

When to Choose Replay vs. Builder.io#

Here's a quick guide to help you decide which platform is right for your needs:

• •

  Choose Replay if:

  • •You need to reconstruct complex UI logic from existing applications.
  • •You want to minimize manual coding and leverage AI-driven code generation.
  • •You need seamless integration with backend services like Supabase.
  • •You prioritize understanding and replicating user behavior.
  • •You are looking to create functional prototypes quickly.
• •

  Choose Builder.io if:

  • •You need a visual editor for building simple landing pages or static content.
  • •You are comfortable with manual coding for complex interactions and logic.
  • •You need fine-grained control over the visual layout of your pages.

Frequently Asked Questions#

Is Replay free to use?#

Replay offers a free tier with limited features. Paid plans are available for more advanced features and usage. Check the Replay website for the latest pricing information.

How is Replay different from v0.dev?#

While both Replay and v0.dev use AI to generate code, Replay focuses on reconstructing existing UIs from video recordings, understanding user behavior, and generating functional code with backend integrations. V0.dev, on the other hand, is primarily focused on generating UI components from text prompts.

Can Replay handle dynamic data?#

Yes, Replay can analyze video recordings of UIs that display dynamic data and generate code to fetch and display that data.

What types of applications is Replay best suited for?#

Replay is well-suited for a wide range of applications, including web applications, mobile applications, and desktop applications. It is particularly useful for reconstructing complex UIs, building prototypes, and generating code for data-driven applications.

---

Ready to try behavior-driven code generation? Get started with Replay - transform any video into working code in seconds.