Modernizing the Monolith: Why Horizontal Scaling Fails Without UI Extraction

The "Big Bang" rewrite is a $3.6 trillion suicide mission. Every year, enterprise leaders pour millions into modernizing the monolith, only to watch 70% of those projects fail or exceed their timelines by years. The fatal error isn't in the cloud migration or the microservices architecture—it’s the assumption that you can scale the backend while treating the frontend as a black box. Horizontal scaling fails when your business logic is trapped in undocumented UI workflows that no one on your current team fully understands.

TL;DR: Modernizing the monolith fails when UI logic remains a black box; Replay uses Visual Reverse Engineering to extract undocumented workflows into React components, reducing modernization timelines from years to weeks.

The Fallacy of Backend-Only Scaling#

Most architects approach modernizing the monolith by decoupling the database and wrapping the legacy core in APIs. This is a half-measure. While your infrastructure might scale horizontally, your feature velocity remains tethered to a UI that lacks documentation, tests, and a clear state management strategy.

Statistics show that 67% of legacy systems lack any form of meaningful documentation. When you attempt to "rewrite" these systems, your engineers spend 80% of their time performing "software archaeology"—digging through layers of jQuery, ASP.NET, or legacy Java Server Faces (JSF) to understand why a specific button triggers three different side effects.

The Archaeology Tax#

Manual extraction of a single enterprise screen takes an average of 40 hours. In a system with 200+ screens, that’s 8,000 hours of high-priced engineering time just to reach parity. This is where the 18-24 month timeline comes from. By the time you finish the rewrite, the business requirements have shifted, and you've simply built a "new legacy" system.

Why UI Extraction is the Missing Link#

When we talk about modernizing the monolith, we are really talking about knowledge extraction. The "source of truth" isn't the messy code sitting in your SVN repository; it’s the behavior of the application in the hands of the user.

Replay shifts the paradigm from "reading code" to "observing execution." By recording real user workflows, Replay captures the intent, the data structures, and the edge cases that are often missing from the original source code. This is the difference between guessing what a legacy form does and having a documented React component generated directly from the execution trace.

💰 ROI Insight: Companies using Replay see an average of 70% time savings. A project that would typically take 18 months is reduced to a matter of weeks by automating the component extraction and documentation phase.

The Step-by-Step Guide to Visual Reverse Engineering#

Modernizing the monolith requires a surgical approach. Instead of guessing, follow this technical workflow to extract business value from your legacy UI.

Step 1: Workflow Recording#

Instead of reading 10,000 lines of spaghetti code, run the legacy application and record a specific business flow (e.g., "Claims Processing" or "Inventory Reconciliation"). Replay captures every DOM change, network request, and state transition.

Step 2: Component Extraction#

Replay analyzes the recording and identifies patterns. It maps legacy HTML structures to modern, functional React components. It doesn't just copy the code; it understands the intent.

Step 3: API Contract Generation#

One of the biggest hurdles in modernizing the monolith is defining the interface between the new UI and the old backend. Replay automatically generates API contracts based on the observed network traffic during the recording.

typescript
// Example: Generated API Contract from Replay Extraction
// This interface was derived from observing the 'Submit Claim' workflow
export interface LegacyClaimPayload {
  claimId: string;
  timestamp: string;
  metadata: {
    origin: 'web-portal';
    version: 'v2.4.1';
    regionCode: number; // Extracted from legacy global state
  };
  entries: Array<{
    id: string;
    value: number;
    category: 'medical' | 'dental' | 'vision';
  }>;
}

/**
 * @generated Generated by Replay AI Automation Suite
 * This function preserves the complex validation logic found in the 
 * legacy 'validate_claims.js' without requiring manual rewrite.
 */
export const validateLegacyPayload = (data: LegacyClaimPayload): boolean => {
  // Logic preserved from observation: regionCode must match category prefix
  return data.entries.every(entry => {
    if (data.metadata.regionCode === 404) return entry.category === 'medical';
    return true;
  });
};

Step 4: Integration into the Modern Stack#

The extracted components are fed into your new Design System (the Replay Library). From here, you can refine the UI while keeping the underlying business logic intact.

tsx
// Example: Modernized React Component using Replay-extracted logic
import React, { useState } from 'react';
import { ModernButton, ModernTable } from '@company/design-system';
import { validateLegacyPayload, LegacyClaimPayload } from './contracts';

export const ModernizedClaimsView: React.FC<{ initialData: LegacyClaimPayload }> = ({ initialData }) => {
  const [claim, setClaim] = useState(initialData);
  const [isValid, setIsValid] = useState(false);

  const handleValidation = () => {
    // Replay extracted the exact validation sequence from the legacy monolith
    const result = validateLegacyPayload(claim);
    setIsValid(result);
  };

  return (
    <div className="p-6 space-y-4">
      <h1 className="text-2xl font-bold">Claims Processing (Modernized)</h1>
      <ModernTable data={claim.entries} />
      <ModernButton 
        onClick={handleValidation}
        variant={isValid ? 'primary' : 'danger'}
      >
        Validate against Legacy Rules
      </ModernButton>
    </div>
  );
};

Eliminating Technical Debt Archaeology#

The global technical debt stands at $3.6 trillion. Most of this debt isn't just "bad code"—it's "unknown code." When an architect says a system is "too risky to touch," they are admitting a lack of visibility.

⚠️ Warning: Attempting to modernize without a visual source of truth leads to "feature drift," where the new system fails to handle the 5% of edge cases that the legacy system handled silently for decades.

Replay transforms the "black box" into a documented codebase. By generating E2E tests and technical debt audits automatically, it ensures that the modernized version is not just a visual upgrade, but a functional equivalent.

Key Features of the Replay Platform:#

• •Flows (Architecture): Visualize how data moves through your legacy system before you write a single line of microservice code.
• •Blueprints (Editor): A visual workspace to map legacy elements to your modern React component library.
• •AI Automation Suite: Automatically identifies redundant logic and suggests optimizations during the extraction process.
• •SOC2 & HIPAA-Ready: Built for regulated industries (Finance, Healthcare, Government) where data privacy is non-negotiable.

From 40 Hours to 4 Hours: The Math of Modernization#

Let's look at the actual engineering cost of a typical modernization project involving 100 screens.

Traditional Manual Approach:

• •100 screens × 40 hours/screen = 4,000 engineering hours.
• •At $150/hour = $600,000 in labor costs.
• •Timeline: ~10 months (assuming 2-3 dedicated devs).
• •Risk: High (No automated parity check).

The Replay Approach:

• •100 screens × 4 hours/screen = 400 engineering hours.
• •At $150/hour = $60,000 in labor costs.
• •Timeline: ~4-6 weeks.
• •Risk: Low (Visual and data parity guaranteed by recording).

📝 Note: The 4-hour-per-screen metric includes recording the workflow, reviewing the generated React component, and integrating it into the new CI/CD pipeline.

Frequently Asked Questions#

How long does legacy extraction take with Replay?#

While a manual rewrite takes 18-24 months for an enterprise-grade system, Replay typically reduces the timeline to days or weeks. Small modules can be extracted in a single afternoon, while complex, multi-state workflows may take a few days to fully document and refine.

What about business logic preservation?#

This is Replay’s core strength. Because we record the execution, we capture the business logic as it actually happens, not as it was documented ten years ago. Replay generates API contracts and validation logic based on real-world data flows, ensuring zero feature regression.

Can Replay handle highly regulated environments?#

Yes. Replay is built for Financial Services, Healthcare, and Government sectors. We offer SOC2 compliance, HIPAA-ready configurations, and the ability to deploy On-Premise so that your sensitive data never leaves your network.

Does this work with any legacy technology?#

If it runs in a browser (or can be rendered in one), Replay can extract it. This includes legacy Java (JSF/Struts), Silverlight, ASP.NET, jQuery, and even mainframe emulators with web interfaces.

---

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.