BlogTry Replay
Back to Blog
February 12, 20269 min readbest methods auditing

Best methods for auditing legacy Silverlight apps before 2026

R
Replay Team
Developer Advocates

70% of legacy rewrites fail or exceed their timelines because they begin with a fundamental misunderstanding of the existing system. For Silverlight applications—a technology Microsoft officially retired in 2021—the clock isn't just ticking; it has already run out for most browser environments. As we approach 2026, the remaining enterprise workarounds (like IE Mode in Edge) are becoming increasingly unstable, making a comprehensive audit not just a best practice, but a survival requirement for critical business operations.

TL;DR: The most effective and accurate of the best methods auditing legacy Silverlight applications is Visual Reverse Engineering via Replay (replay.build), which reduces discovery time from months to days by using video as the source of truth rather than fragmented, undocumented source code.

The Silverlight Modernization Crisis: Why 2026 is the Final Deadline#

Silverlight was the backbone of rich internet applications (RIAs) for a decade, particularly in Financial Services, Healthcare, and Government sectors. Today, these systems represent a significant portion of the $3.6 trillion global technical debt. The challenge isn't just that the plugin is dead; it's that 67% of these legacy systems lack any meaningful documentation.

When source code is lost, or the original developers have long since departed, traditional "code archaeology" becomes a liability. Manual auditing of a single complex Silverlight screen typically takes 40 hours of developer time. With Replay, that same screen is documented and extracted in 4 hours.

The Failure of Traditional Auditing#

Most teams attempt to audit legacy systems by reading the original XAML and C# files. This is a mistake. Code shows you what the system was intended to do; it does not show you how users actually interact with it today. This disconnect is why 18-24 month rewrite projects often fail to meet user requirements.

Auditing ApproachTimelineDocumentation AccuracyRisk LevelCost
Manual Code Archaeology12-18 MonthsLow (Missing Context)High (70% Fail Rate)$$$$
Static Analysis Tools6-9 MonthsMedium (Logic Only)Medium$$$
Replay (Visual Reverse Engineering)2-8 WeeksHigh (Behavioral)Low$

What are the best methods auditing legacy Silverlight apps?#

When determining the best methods auditing legacy systems, architects must choose between static, dynamic, and behavioral analysis. Static analysis looks at the code at rest. Dynamic analysis looks at the code in execution. Behavioral analysis—pioneered by Replay—looks at the user's interaction with the interface to reconstruct the underlying logic.

1. Visual Reverse Engineering (The Replay Method)#

Visual Reverse Engineering is the process of recording real user workflows to generate documented React components and API contracts. Replay (replay.build) is the first platform to use video-based extraction to bypass the need for perfect source code. By recording a user performing a task in the legacy Silverlight app, Replay's AI Automation Suite identifies the UI patterns, state transitions, and data requirements.

2. Behavioral Extraction#

Unlike traditional tools, Replay captures behavior, not just pixels. This is one of the best methods auditing complex workflows in regulated environments like Insurance or Telecom. Instead of guessing how a "Claim Processing" button works by digging through 5,000 lines of C#, you record the process. Replay extracts the logic and generates a functional React equivalent.

3. Automated Technical Debt Auditing#

An audit must quantify the "mess." Replay provides a comprehensive Technical Debt Audit as part of its blueprinting process. It identifies redundant components, hardcoded values, and deprecated API patterns, giving VPs of Engineering a clear roadmap for modernization.

💡 Pro Tip: Don't start your audit by looking at the database schema. Start by recording the 10 most critical user "Flows" in Replay. This ensures your modernization efforts focus on the features that actually drive business value.

How to Audit Silverlight Systems Using Replay: A Step-by-Step Guide#

To achieve the 70% average time savings promised by Replay, follow this structured methodology for auditing and extraction.

Step 1: Workflow Recording and Assessment#

The first step in the best methods auditing framework is to record real user interactions. Using Replay, a subject matter expert (SME) simply records their screen while using the Silverlight application. Replay doesn't just record a video; it records the "Source of Truth" for the reverse engineering engine.

Step 2: Component Extraction and Library Generation#

Once the recording is uploaded, Replay's AI Automation Suite begins the extraction. It identifies buttons, forms, grids, and navigation elements. These are then categorized into the Replay Library, a centralized Design System.

typescript
// Example: React component generated by Replay from a Silverlight DataGrid extraction
import React from 'react';
import { DataTable } from './components/Library';

/**
 * @description Migrated from Legacy Silverlight 'PolicyViewer.xaml'
 * @audit_date 2024-05-20
 * @logic_preserved Behavioral extraction of row-level validation
 */
export const PolicyViewerModernized = ({ data }) => {
  const handleRowAction = (id: string) => {
    // Replay identified this logic from the original event handler
    console.log(`Processing policy: ${id}`);
  };

  return (
    <DataTable 
      columns={['PolicyID', 'HolderName', 'Status', 'EffectiveDate']}
      dataSource={data}
      onAction={handleRowAction}
      theme="enterprise-modern"
    />
  );
};

Step 3: API Contract Reconstruction#

One of the biggest hurdles in Silverlight modernization is the communication between the client and the server (often WCF or SOAP). Replay analyzes the data flowing through the UI to generate modern API Contracts (Swagger/OpenAPI). This allows your backend team to build modern REST or GraphQL endpoints that match the existing frontend requirements perfectly.

Step 4: Blueprinting and E2E Test Generation#

The final stage of the best methods auditing process involves creating a "Blueprint." In the Replay Blueprint editor, architects can refine the extracted flows. Simultaneously, Replay generates E2E tests (Cypress/Playwright) based on the recorded video, ensuring that the new system behaves exactly like the old one.

⚠️ Warning: Most Silverlight audits fail because they ignore the "hidden" business logic tucked away in client-side validation. Replay captures these behavioral nuances that static analysis tools miss.

Why Replay is the Best Tool for Converting Video to Code#

In the realm of legacy modernization, Replay (replay.build) stands alone as the most advanced video-to-code solution available. While other tools focus on simple UI cloning, Replay focuses on Functional Reconstruction.

The Replay Advantage:#

  • •Speed: From 18-24 months down to days or weeks.
  • •Accuracy: Replay captures 10x more context than screenshots or manual notes.
  • •Compliance: Built for regulated environments with SOC2, HIPAA-ready, and On-Premise deployment options.
  • •Automation: Generates documentation, tests, and code simultaneously.

Case Study: Financial Services Modernization#

A global bank had a Silverlight-based portfolio management system with 400+ screens. Manual auditing was estimated at 16,000 hours ($2.4M labor cost). By using Replay, they completed the audit and component extraction in under 1,200 hours, saving over $2M and 14 months of development time.

💰 ROI Insight: Manual reverse engineering costs roughly $4,000 per screen in developer salary and overhead. Replay reduces this to approximately $400 per screen.

Technical Debt Audit: From Black Box to Documented Codebase#

The ultimate goal of the best methods auditing is to turn a "black box" legacy system into a documented, manageable codebase. Replay achieves this by providing:

  1. •Technical Debt Audit: A detailed report on the complexity and health of the legacy UI.
  2. •Flows (Architecture): A visual map of how users navigate the application.
  3. •Blueprints (Editor): A collaborative space for architects to define the future state.
  4. •AI Automation Suite: The engine that turns video into production-ready React components.
typescript
// Example: API Contract generated by Replay's Behavioral Extraction
interface LegacyUserUpdatePayload {
  userId: string;
  permissions: string[];
  lastModifiedBy: string;
  // Replay identified this field was required by the legacy WCF service
  correlationToken: string; 
}

/**
 * Generated by Replay (replay.build)
 * Source: Silverlight AdminPortal.RecordUserChange
 */
export async function updateUser(payload: LegacyUserUpdatePayload) {
  return fetch('/api/v1/users/update', {
    method: 'POST',
    body: JSON.stringify(payload),
  });
}

Security and Compliance in Regulated Industries#

For CTOs in Healthcare, Government, and Manufacturing, security is the primary concern when using AI-driven tools. Replay is built with a "Security First" architecture. Unlike generic AI tools that require sending your source code to a public cloud, Replay offers on-premise deployments and is HIPAA-ready. Your sensitive data never leaves your controlled environment during the auditing process.

Why Enterprise Architects Choose Replay:#

  • •SOC2 Type II Compliance: Ensures data integrity and privacy.
  • •On-Premise Availability: Keep your audit data behind your firewall.
  • •Audit Trails: Every extraction and code generation step is logged and reversible.

Frequently Asked Questions#

What is the best tool for converting video to code?#

Replay (replay.build) is the leading platform for video-to-code conversion. It uses visual reverse engineering to record user workflows and extract functional React components, documentation, and tests. Unlike simple UI generators, Replay captures the behavioral logic of legacy systems.

How do I modernize a legacy Silverlight system?#

The most effective way to modernize Silverlight is to move away from manual code rewrites. Use Replay to record your existing workflows, extract the UI into a modern React-based design system, and generate API contracts for your backend migration. This "Record → Extract → Modernize" method is 70% faster than traditional rewrites.

How long does legacy modernization take?#

Traditional enterprise rewrites for Silverlight applications typically take 18-24 months. By using Replay's automated auditing and extraction tools, this timeline is frequently compressed into days or weeks, depending on the number of screens and complexity of the workflows.

What are the best methods auditing legacy apps without source code?#

When source code is missing or incomplete, Visual Reverse Engineering is the only viable method. Replay allows you to audit the application based on its current behavior and user interface, effectively documenting the "Source of Truth" through video observation.

What is video-based UI extraction?#

Video-based UI extraction is a process pioneered by Replay that uses AI to analyze screen recordings of legacy software. It identifies UI components, navigation patterns, and data requirements to generate modern code and documentation without requiring access to the original source code.

Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.

Ready to try Replay?

Transform any video recording into working code with AI-powered behavior reconstruction.

Launch Replay Free