Most enterprise rewrites in healthcare fail before the first line of code is even committed to production. In regulated environments, the "Big Bang" rewrite isn't just a technical risk—it’s a compliance nightmare. When you are dealing with HIPAA-regulated systems, the traditional "archaeology" phase of modernization—where developers spend months digging through undocumented COBOL or Java monoliths—frequently leads to accidental exposure of Protected Health Information (PHI) and massive budget overruns.
The global technical debt currently sits at $3.6 trillion. For a CTO in healthcare or insurance, that debt manifests as a 18-24 month rewrite timeline that has a 70% chance of failure. The bottleneck isn't the new stack; it's understanding the old one.
TL;DR: Automated UI extraction leverages video as the source of truth to convert legacy workflows into documented React components, reducing modernization timelines from years to weeks while maintaining strict HIPAA compliance.
The High Cost of Manual Archaeology#
67% of legacy systems lack any form of up-to-date documentation. In a HIPAA-compliant environment, this gap is usually filled by "shadow documentation"—spreadsheets and Jira tickets maintained by subject matter experts (SMEs) who are the only ones who know how the system actually works.
When you attempt to modernize these systems manually, you face a brutal reality: it takes an average of 40 hours to document, design, and re-code a single complex enterprise screen. In a system with 500+ screens, you are looking at years of manual labor.
| Approach | Timeline | Risk | Cost | Documentation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Big Bang Rewrite | 18-24 months | High (70% fail) | $$$$ | Manual / Outdated |
| Strangler Fig | 12-18 months | Medium | $$$ | Partial |
| Automated UI Extraction | 2-8 weeks | Low | $ | Real-time / Visual |
Replay changes this math by shifting the source of truth from the codebase (which is often a mess of technical debt) to the user workflow. By recording real user interactions, Replay uses visual reverse engineering to extract the underlying logic and UI structure.
How Automated UI Extraction Maintains HIPAA Integrity#
In a regulated environment, you cannot simply hand over a production database or a live system access to a modernization team. Automated UI extraction solves this by focusing on the intent of the interface rather than the sensitive data within it.
1. Metadata over Data#
When Replay records a workflow, it isn't just capturing pixels. It is capturing the DOM structure, the state transitions, and the API requirements. For HIPAA systems, this means the extraction process can be configured to ignore PII/PHI while still capturing the functional requirements of the component.
2. On-Premise Execution#
For organizations with the strictest security requirements, Replay offers on-premise deployment. This ensures that no data—meta or otherwise—ever leaves your secure perimeter. You get the speed of AI-driven automation with the security of a localized environment.
⚠️ Warning: Traditional "Screen Scraping" tools often capture static images that might contain PHI. True automated UI extraction should focus on the structural components and state logic, not just the visual layer.
The Technical Reality: From Video to React#
The output of automated UI extraction isn't just a wireframe; it’s a functional, documented codebase. Replay generates React components that mirror the legacy system's behavior but utilize a modern, clean architecture.
Below is an example of a component generated via extraction from a legacy healthcare portal. Note how the business logic is preserved while the UI is modernized.
typescript// Generated by Replay - Legacy Patient Intake Extraction import React, { useState, useEffect } from 'react'; import { Button, TextField, Alert } from '@/components/ui'; // From Replay Library import { validateHIPAACompliance } from '@/utils/validators'; interface PatientIntakeProps { initialData?: any; onSave: (data: any) => Promise<void>; } export const PatientIntakeForm: React.FC<PatientIntakeProps> = ({ onSave }) => { const [formData, setFormData] = useState({ patientName: '', ssnLastFour: '', consentSigned: false }); const [error, setError] = useState<string | null>(null); // Business logic extracted from legacy workflow: // Triggered when SSN field loses focus in original system const handleValidation = () => { if (!validateHIPAACompliance(formData)) { setError("Validation failed: Ensure all mandatory privacy fields are checked."); } }; return ( <div className="p-6 bg-white rounded-lg shadow-md"> <h2 className="text-xl font-bold mb-4">Patient Information</h2> {error && <Alert variant="destructive">{error}</Alert>} <TextField label="Patient Name" value={formData.patientName} onChange={(val) => setFormData({...formData, patientName: val})} /> <TextField label="SSN (Last 4)" value={formData.ssnLastFour} onBlur={handleValidation} onChange={(val) => setFormData({...formData, ssnLastFour: val})} /> <Button onClick={() => onSave(formData)} className="mt-4"> Save Records </Button> </div> ); };
💡 Pro Tip: When using Replay, focus your first recordings on "Happy Path" workflows. This allows the AI Automation Suite to establish a baseline for your Design System (Library) before tackling edge cases and error states.
Step-by-Step: The Replay Modernization Workflow#
Modernizing a HIPAA-compliant system requires a surgical approach. We move from a "Black Box" to a fully documented, modern codebase in four distinct phases.
Step 1: Assessment and Recording#
Instead of reading through 10-year-old documentation, SMEs record their standard workflows using Replay. This captures exactly how the system is used today, not how it was designed to be used a decade ago.
Step 2: Visual Extraction (Blueprints)#
Replay’s AI analyzes the recording to identify patterns. It recognizes recurring UI elements (buttons, inputs, tables) and maps them to a centralized Library. This creates a consistent Design System across the entire enterprise.
Step 3: API Contract Generation#
One of the biggest hurdles in healthcare modernization is the backend. Replay generates API contracts based on the data requirements observed during the UI extraction.
json// Example: Generated API Contract for Legacy Patient Service { "endpoint": "/api/v1/patient/update", "method": "POST", "required_fields": [ "patient_id", "provider_id", "encrypted_payload" ], "security": { "type": "OAuth2", "scope": "patient.write" } }
Step 4: Technical Debt Audit and Validation#
Before any code is deployed, Replay provides a Technical Debt Audit. It identifies redundant logic, unused fields, and potential security vulnerabilities that existed in the legacy system so they aren't carried over to the new React-based frontend.
Why Technical Decision Makers are Switching to Replay#
The traditional "Rewrite" is a gamble with a 30% success rate. For a VP of Engineering in a regulated industry, those odds are unacceptable. Replay reduces the time spent on manual screen recreation from 40 hours to 4 hours—a 90% reduction in manual effort.
- •Speed: From 18 months to weeks.
- •Accuracy: Video extraction ensures no business logic is missed.
- •Security: SOC2, HIPAA-ready, and On-Premise options.
- •Maintainability: Generates clean, documented React code instead of "spaghetti" logic.
💰 ROI Insight: For a medium-sized healthcare application with 200 screens, manual modernization costs approximately $1.2M in developer hours. Using Replay's automated extraction, that cost drops to under $200k, while simultaneously generating full documentation and E2E tests.
Solving the Documentation Gap#
67% of legacy systems lack documentation, which is why most modernization projects stall during the "discovery" phase. Replay eliminates discovery by making it visual.
When you record a workflow, Replay generates:
- •Flows: A visual map of the application architecture.
- •Blueprints: An editable version of the extracted UI.
- •E2E Tests: Automated tests that ensure the new system behaves exactly like the old one.
This "Video as source of truth" approach ensures that even if your lead architect leaves the company mid-project, the knowledge of how the system functions is preserved within the Replay platform.
Frequently Asked Questions#
How does Replay ensure PHI isn't captured during recording?#
Replay utilizes field-level masking and structural extraction. Instead of capturing the content of a patient record, it captures the structure of the data field (e.g., "Patient Name Input"). For high-security environments, our On-Premise deployment ensures that all processing happens within your secure network, and PII can be scrubbed before the AI extraction layer processes the UI components.
What happens to the business logic hidden in the legacy backend?#
While Replay focuses on UI extraction, it generates the API contracts required to support that UI. This gives your backend teams a clear specification of what the new API needs to provide, effectively "strangling" the legacy backend logic and allowing for a phased migration of business rules.
Can we use our own Design System with Replay?#
Yes. Replay’s Library feature allows you to map extracted legacy components to your existing modern Design System. If the legacy system uses a non-standard button, Replay can automatically replace it with your approved React/Tailwind button component during the extraction process.
What frameworks does Replay support for the output?#
Replay primarily generates high-quality React components (TypeScript), but the underlying Blueprints can be used to generate code for other modern frameworks. The generated code follows industry best practices, including accessibility (A11y) standards and modular state management.
Ready to modernize without rewriting? Book a pilot with Replay - see your legacy screen extracted live during the call.